A powerful op-ed in yesterday’s Jakarta Post by Ristian Atriandi Supriyanto from ANU indicts the 2015 Indonesian Defense White Paper for its “superficial” treatment of Indonesia’s maritime security challenges. But more importantly, it identifies a disturbing emphasis on bela negara as central to Indonesia’s strategic defense outlook.
I have been critical of bela negara before. One common set of responses that I received at the time was that this program wasn’t going to be taken very seriously by most Indonesians, that it lacked a clear funding mechanism, and so forth. That much may still be true, but it is meaningful that the national strategic defense policy currently devotes such attention to bela negara. From the introduction to the English version of the white paper (pdf here), we read the following description
National defence is managed in a total defence system to achieve its national goals. The system is essentially a defence involving all citizens in accordance with their roles and functions. The involvement of every citizen in national defence is in-line-with the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. A State Defence Programme, or defined as Bela Negara programme, is implemented within the next decade and expected to reach 100 million citizens who are militant. This programme will continually develop the needs of national defence.
Concepts like citizens having “roles and functions” are reminiscent of corporatist ideology under Indonesia’s New Order. Remember, Golkar literally means “functional groups.”