Seymour Hersh, in the New Yorker, March 30, 2015:
the U.S. military, convinced that the Vietcong were entrenched in central Vietnam and attracting serious support, made little distinction between combatants and noncombatants in the area that included My Lai.
The problem of separating insurgents from neutrals/loyalists is at the core of counterinsurgency warfare. Nearly fifty years on, We are still coming to grips with just how deep this problem ran in Vietnam.
My last post comparing Singapore’s growth trajectory to the narrative of Singapore as a “Third World” country garnered some fairly wide interest. And some pushback, of course. The most significant is the fair point that rankings of economic output do not tell us much about what it was like to live in Singapore at independence.
Courtesy of my friend and colleague Jeff Petersen at the Cornell library, here is some more evocative evidence. It’s a video made in 1957; I don’t know anything about it, but it looks like a Singapore sales pitch, probably by Malayan Airways, geared towards a Western audience.
The narration says it all.
At first, it looks like any other Eastern city. But if you’re used to Eastern cities, you’ll notice how clean this one is…
Here is the world in miniature, in a city proud to find room for so much, and taking its very character from the people it shelters…
Of all, perhaps, it’s a shopper’s paradise…a glittering showcase of exotic goods…
The major delight of such a cosmopolitan city is the food…
The continuity with contemporary Singapore is staggering.
Personally, I’m delighted to see these old images of Arab Street, Sree Maha Mariamman temple, and other familiar haunts.
Tom Pepinsky 