The Benefits of Peer Reviewing

There is a great article on peer reviewing (sorry, gated) by Beth Miller, Jon Pevehouse, Ron Rogowski, Dustin Tingley, and Rick Wilson in the current issue of PS: Political Science and Politics (HT Marc Bellemare). My favorite part of the article is not the guidelines on how to be a good peer reviewer, but why it is important to review manuscripts even if you are purely and utterly selfish. Peer reviewing, after all, can take a lot of time, and is viewed as an onerous task that distracts from other professional activities like research, writing, teaching, and going to get coffee. I quote at length:

  • Refereeing allows you to keep up with cutting-edge research in your sub-field, while also helping to keep your sights set more broadly;
  • Too often, we only see the final product, which can give us a false sense of elegance. Reviewing manuscripts in their early stages reminds us that everyone (and every published bit of research) has to go through a process of refinement;
  • By exposing you to diverse examples and writing styles, reviewing allows you develop an appreciation of effective writing and helps you improve as a writer;
  • Related, refereeing allows you to understand and apply the subtle differences between writing papers for seminars, conferences, and journals;
  • Finally, many academic journals allow reviewers to see the other reviews of the same manuscript, which allows you to assess your own review and compare your assessment of a manuscript to what other researchers think about it. It also allows you to see how much disagreement may prevail in evaluating even important manuscripts.

I could not have said this better myself. One thing to note among these comments is the emphasis on improving your own writing by reading and critically evaluating others’ work. I think that PhD students, especially, fail to appreciate just how important writing is: style, form, clarity, argument, all the things that you learn in high school English class.

Posted in Research
On Twitter
Categories
Archives
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,736 other followers

%d bloggers like this: